An extraordinary opportunity awaits in Northern Indiana at 944 South Shore Drive on Lake Maxinkuckee in Culver, which just hit the market for $19.9 million and is represented exclusively by Andrea Kelly, of Encore Sotheby’s International Realty. Curated and owned by the renowned Irsay family, this unparalleled property offers over 250 feet of private shoreline, the largest private dock on the lake, and more than 35,000 square feet of meticulously crafted living and recreational spaces across two connected parcels.
The estate’s provenance reflects the enduring legacy of the Irsay family, widely recognized for their philanthropic leadership in Indiana and their stewardship of the Indianapolis Colts since 1972. Long held as a cherished private retreat, the property combines heritage and privacy with a lifestyle defined by luxury, scale, and the natural beauty of one of Indiana’s most iconic lakes.
Photos by The Addison Group
At the heart of the estate is the stunning main residence, a European-inspired masterpiece with 13,956 square feet of gracious living spaces, featuring soaring timber-framed ceilings, hand-painted details, and expansive floor-to-ceiling windows framing breathtaking lake views. With 8 bedrooms and 10 full plus 2 half bathrooms across four levels (with partial elevator access), the home is designed to host generations of family and friends and includes spacious entertaining areas including the rare walkout lower level, multiple screened sleeping porches, and private quarters tailored for comfort and elegance.
Photos by The Addison Group
Complementing the main home is a wellness-focused indoor pool house – a serene retreat offering year-round swimming and spa amenities. It has retractable lake-facing doors for true indoor/outdoor living, plus a hot tub, heated paver pool deck, fireplace lounge area, plant wall, steam room, and fitness areas.
The guest house, located on the parcel behind the main residence provides warm, inviting accommodations for visitors or estate staff and includes an 8-car garage for vehicle storage, toys and recreational equipment.
Photos by The Addison Group
The property’s rare and lengthy lake frontage is enhanced by the largest private dock on Lake Maxinkuckee, featuring over 4,000 square feet of dock space, two boat slips, and three solar-powered lifts. Other well-appointed outdoor living areas include a firepit lounge, sand volleyball court, and expansive terraces designed for relaxation and hosting guests, all overlooking the pristine lake.
Photos by The Addison Group
An entertainment complex with Creston smart automation on the adjoining parcel offers additional lifestyle amenities including a professional-grade 4-lane bowling alley, arcade gaming area, state-of-the-art indoor shooting range, and a club-style bar with seating for 20 – ideal for hosting guests or enjoying leisure in privacy.
Photos by The Addison Group
A discreet 350-foot underground tunnel connects the parcels, housing mechanicals away from the main residence to preserve the peaceful lakefront environment.
Offered at $19.9 million, 944 South Shore Drive presents an extraordinary opportunity to acquire a rare lakefront compound embodying the finest Midwest luxury living – unmatched in scope, amenities, and timeless appeal.
For more information or to request a private viewing, please contact the listing agent, Andrea Kelly, of Encore Sotheby’s International Realty at 317.840.4056 or andrea.kelly@encoresothebysrealty.com. She is known for her tailored, client-first approach and deep knowledge of Indiana’s luxury market. Her background in new construction, design, and relocation makes her a go-to expert for buyers and sellers seeking exceptional service and results.
Encore Sotheby’s International Realty is a boutique residential real estate brokerage providing home sellers and buyers with a luxury level of service in Indiana and beyond. Specializing in the central, northeast and northwest regions of Indiana, the firm operates out of offices in Carmel, Indianapolis, Zionsville and Fort Wayne. Backed by the world-class Sotheby’s International Realty brand, clients benefit from local expertise with global reach. For all of your real estate needs, call 317.660.4444 or visit encoresothebysrealty.com.
The Art of Distinction Blog by Encore Sotheby's International Realty 
Leave a comment