The Art of Distinction Blog by Encore Sotheby's International Realty

An unparalleled piece of Fort Wayne’s history has just been listed for sale, and it’s capturing the attention of art and history enthusiasts alike. 1202 W. Wayne Street in Fort Wayne is recently listed by Lynn Reecer and Dianne Hovermale of Encore Sotheby’s International Realty. This unique single-family residence, previously known as the Fort Wayne Museum of Art, is now available for new ownership. With a rich history of over 30 years as one of the Midwest’s premier art galleries, this exquisite property is ready to embrace a new chapter.

Nestled in the heart of the historical West Central neighborhood in downtown Fort Wayne, Indiana, this 1905 granite stone structure is distinct and exudes a timeless charm. The property’s large front porch is a telling welcome of the artistic journey that awaits within.

“Castle Gallery has been my favorite destination in Fort Wayne even since I first visited many years ago. When recruiting new talent to Fort Wayne with my other business, NE Indiana Talent Attraction, I always take job candidates here and they fall instantly in love with this local historical gem,” Lynn Reecer, the listing agent, said.

Upon entering, there is a grand receiving foyer and living room featuring a tiled mosaic fireplace and expansive windows that provide a captivating view of Wayne Street. The adjacent dining room boasts wood built-ins, parquet flooring, and a coffered ceiling.

This property offers three kitchens, and a separate reception/bar area that caters to entertaining enthusiasts. Throughout the home, Tiffany-stained glass windows infuse multiple rooms with vibrant colors and artistic allure. A hand-carved wooden staircase stands as an architectural masterpiece, guiding visitors to the second floor. The main bedroom, nestled in the home’s turret, includes a fireplace and an en-suite bathroom, creating a private sanctuary.

There are patios on all three floors, encouraging seamless indoor/outdoor living. The home contains original, exposed oak beams and brickwork. Cozy sleeping lofts add a playful element to the space, making it especially appealing for families.

To round out the property, there is a large unfinished basement and a spacious four-car garage equipped with electricity and water—a rare find in historical homes. With three half baths, five full baths (four of which are en-suite), and seven bedrooms, this listing accommodates both family living and overnight guests. For added peace of mind, the property is equipped with a security alarm system.

This is a unique opportunity to own a piece of Fort Wayne’s history and make it your own. Whether you envision this magnificent property as your new residence or as a venue to continue the tradition of operating an art gallery, as the previous owners did for three decades, this property promises an exceptional and memorable experience.

For more information and to schedule viewings, please contact Lynn Reecer at 260.434.5750 or Dianne Hovermale at 765.667.0359 or visit encoresothebysrealty.com.

Encore Sotheby’s International Realty offers home sellers and buyers an extraordinary level of service throughout central, northeast and northwest Indiana. With offices located in Carmel, Indianapolis, Zionsville, Fort Wayne and Lake Wawasee they are Indiana real estate experts, backed by the world-class Sotheby’s International Realty brand. For all of your real estate needs, call 317.660.4444 or visit encoresothebysrealty.com.